Is the Cyprus construction boom sustainable?

Is the Cyprus construction boom sustainable?THERE is an evident upswing in the sale of construction materials and what appears to be a nascent revival in the whole property and development sector.

More homes and other development projects are being built than in recent years, especially after the bubble at the beginning of this decade that gave way to the mortgage crisis and near collapse of the banking sector.

The question that needs to be asked is whether there is sustainable demand for new houses or is it just the result of the investment-for-passports scheme attracting overseas buyers of homes, expensive high-rises and other such high-value projects.

Some fear that what is happening in the property sector is another bubble in the making with two or three more years before it bursts.

Nearly half of all property contracts deposited at the Land Registry offices in the first half of the year were for properties purchased by non-Cypriots, a number that could dwindle if the government continues to restrict the number of property-for-passport investors to 700 a year.

This means that instead of the property development sector relying on more sustainable markets (student housing, locals buying first homes and holiday homes, buy-to-let investors, etc.).

We are seemingly, again, rushing to desperately find overseas buyers, with the hope that apart from boosting state coffers, these investments will also subsidise efforts to bring down unemployment.

Limassol could soon face the possibility of hosting yet another Costa Del Sol bonanza with open spaces and green areas being sacrificed in the name of high-rise development and quickly-found prosperity.

Then again, apart from the accountants and lawyers, what other sectors of the economy are benefitting from the sale of expensive properties to foreign investors? And how many of these luxury developments are going to be occupied permanently?

With many of these properties expected to remain empty, it will not take long for them to fall into disrepair, projecting an image of a ‘ghost town’ or shabby skyscrapers.

For sure, the establishment of a casino resort will greatly contribute to supporting the property sector, but gaming alone is not a sustainable reason for holidaymakers to become property buyers.

Cyprus needs to look at alternative scenarios and think more seriously about how to maintain steady, even if small, growth in tourism numbers, as long as these will generate the sort of repeat visitors we need.

Otherwise, this will be just another boom-bust cycle in our tourism/property sectors, with economic growth and employment levels held hostage to the whims of greedy developers who are in it for a quick buck and are not obliged to see the bigger picture or the longer-term view.

Therefore, the authorities are urged to consider sustainable construction growth when issuing town planning and building permits.

Cyprus construction industry enjoying a revival

Cyprus construction industry enjoying a revivalTHE FEDERATION of the Building Constructors Associations of Cyprus (OSEOK) says things are looking as developers see a bright future as big projects are in the pipeline, while others are expected to be announced.

The manager of OSEOK, Frangos Prokopas said that the sector has seen an upward swing that begun in 2017 and has continued into 2018.

He said the federation’s Activity Index has recorded a positive trend for the first time since 2010, standing at +12%. The Activity Index measures the percentage of developers who stated that they saw their business grow in 2017.

Meanwhile, the Work Cycle Index of the Federation measuring the percentage of contractors who have declared that their work load for 2017 was above normal or expected, minus the percentage of those who declare it to be below the norm, recorded a significant improvement too, standing at -37%. The index improved from -92% at the end of 2013, with the base year being 2007

“However, these indices should not be taken literally but should be used as indicators rather than measurements of how many developers actually saw their business grow,” Prokopas said.

He explained that one should look at the trend of the index.

“For example, the Activity index in December 2013 stood at -74%. It was a time were a lot of smaller developers closed shop. Now we see these smaller developers, reopening their businesses and taking on projects along with bigger contractors,” said Prokopas.

He said smaller developers are being sub-contracted by bigger firms who, due to layoffs and other cuts made during the 2013 crisis, do not have the necessary staff or infrastructure to cope with big projects.

But now developers are rather optimistic regarding the future as major projects are in the pipeline or expected to be announced.

“Public works had been put on ice during the previous years and the sector is now anticipating the declaration of big public projects by the government,” added Prokopas.

Between 2013-2018, apart from road works, no big construction projects were put forward by the state. Prokopas said that public works to be announced coupled with the construction of a number of high-rises on the Limassol and Paphos coast – which are to take off in the next few years – will give a serious boost to the sector.

Prokopas is encouraged that the sector has started to disengage itself from its dependence on projects connected with the investment for citizenship scheme. He said that the focus of the construction sector is currently concentrated in two main activities, apart from luxury projects on the southwestern coast of Cyprus. He said that there is a significant number of houses being built in the capital.

“In Nicosia we see houses of all sizes being built, with a large number of luxury houses also being raised,” said Prokopas. He added that in Limassol there is a rise in demand for apartments as offshore companies, involved in the natural gas exploration, are bringing more employees to the town.

Prokopas insistence that a significant part of the industry’s activity is concentrated on housing are backed by Cystat figures showing that 70.4% of the 1,984 building permits issued in the first four months of 2018 were for residencies.

Furthermore, fortifying the argument that the industry is turning to the local market, 744 of building permits were issued for projects in Nicosia, a market dominated by Cypriot buyers.

A real estate analyst told the paper that is comes as no surprise that a significant chunk of activity regards the construction of houses. “It’s only natural that the key finding of all reports surrounding the sector is that a significant chunk of the industry’s activity concerns housing.”

“Neither should it come as a surprise that Nicosia is leading the statistics regarding building permits,” the analyst added.

Similar surveys found that Nicosia has seen property sales go from 1,200 in 2016 to 1,485 in 2017.

The analyst explained that the housing needs of locals were put on ice during the years of the crisis as people were living with uncertainty of the times.

“Now as the economy is stabilizing, people feel more confident to take out a mortgage, as the banks have started to give out loans, or to invest cash they have been saving up over the past five years.”

The analyst also said that the significant increase in numbers of students studying at the Nicosia based universities has created a shortage in housing which has pushed up demand. That along with the various student dorm projects being carried out, a significant number of blocks of flats are being build.

“I’m encouraged that the building sector is reinventing itself and becoming more diverse and less dependent on one type of investment.”

A word of caution

Veteran property watcher Nigel Howarth is not so convinced about the sector making positive strides.

“I believe there’s another bubble in the making and I give it two or three years before it bursts,” said Howarth the editor of Cyprus Property News.

He said nearly 50% of the property contracts deposited at Land Registry offices in the first half of the year were for properties purchased by non-Cypriots – and out of the total number of 4,470, almost a third (1,522) were for properties bought by third-country nationals.

“I don’t know how many of these third-country nationals bought in the hope of obtaining Cypriot citizenship. But as the government is restricting the number to 700 a year, I expect quite a few are going to be disappointed. “

Howarth said selling expensive properties like high-rise developments was not really benefitting the economy.

“And how many of these expensive developments are going to be occupied permanently? How long is it going to take them to fall into disrepair?”

There is also the problem in the banking sector with non-performing loans.

“The Cyprus construction sector has the highest ratio of non-performing loans in Europe (74.9%) – it’s even worse than Greece (67.1%). The real estate sector doesn’t do much better – it’s non-performing loan ratio is 39.3%, the third highest level in Europe.”

Cyprus consumer protection decisions

OVER the past few weeks, the Cyprus Consumer Protection Service (CCPS) has issued decisions against Alpha Bank Cyprus Ltd (former Emporiki Bank – Cyprus Ltd), Geormaride Ltd and VM Development Ltd.

Alpha Bank Cyprus

Following its investigation into abusive clauses in a housing loan given in 2008, the CCPS ruled that the bank violated the law on abusive clauses in consumer contracts. These included:

  • calculation of the interest over 360 days;
  • the right of the bank to change the basic rate, the margin, commission and fees at its discretion;
  • the right of the bank to demand partial or full payment of the loan, interest, commission and expenses with additional interest charges if the consumer fails to do so;
  • the right of the bank to join or merge all of any of the consumer’s accounts, or to transfer money from any of the consumer’s accounts to pay all or part of his/her obligations to the banks;
  • the right of the bank to accept a proposal from the consumer for early repayment of the loan and the payment by the consumer of any expenses, costs, losses (including loss of profits) which the bank may sustain from an early repayment.

Property developer Geormaride Ltd

The CCPS ruled that a sales contract prepared by the company contained abusive clauses that:

  • required consumers to fulfil their payments before the company had transferred the title deeds;
  • imposed a high interest on late payments;
  • burdened consumers with taxes and expenses which should be paid after the property is transferred;
  • required consumers to sign a management agreement for the common areas which was not attached to the sales contract, thereby committing them to conditions they could not have known.

Property developer VM Development Ltd

The CCPS imposed an administrative fine of €200,000 on the company for breaching the Unfair Commercial Practices of Businesses to Consumers Law.

The company built homes without first obtaining the necessary licences from authorities.

Consequently the CCPS concluded that contracts for the sale of property without disclosing the actual situation of the properties to their purchasers and the consequences that arise in relation to transferring absolute ownership and title deeds the buyers.

The Cyprus Land and Building Developers Association (LBDA) issued a statement saying that the company was not one of its members and called on its members follow the laws and regulations.

The LBDA noted that the transfer of title deeds on the sale of a property is the “best way” to protect buyers and does away with the need for expensive and bureaucratic laws, such as the ‘trapped buyers’ law..

Further reading

The decisions of the Cyprus Consumer Protection Service may be viewed (in Greek) by clicking here.

Paphos high-rise resort gets off the ground

Cyprus: Paphos high-rise devcelopment GeroskipouA PROPOSED €3.4 billion resort development project in Geroskipou, Paphos has been given the go ahead with building permits issued to construct two 12-storey high-rises with a total of 122 apartments.

The residential development, called Peninsula resort, is part of the larger 200-hectare Eden City Cyprus project, a joint venture of the Archbishop of Cyprus and ATUM Developments Ltd, headed by Hungarian tycoon Sandor Kenyeres.

The Peninsula Resort phase was given the green light by the Town Planning Department after the Department of Antiquities submitted a positive report regarding the planned construction in the area belonging to the Church of Cyprus.

The Antiquities Department and the consortium are in complete agreement regarding the protection of archaeological remnants located within the site in question.

It is also expected that the Department of Antiquities will continue its excavations in the western part of the site, where the company plans to build a luxury hotel but has not taken any action pending the completion of the building permits procedure.

The Peninsula Resort, according to the environmental study filed with the Environment Department, is to include a 14-storey five-star hotel (the largest tower) with 220 rooms and two 12-storey high-rises with a total of 122 apartments, at an estimated cost of more than €100 mln.

Eden City consists of three parts: the Peninsula Resort, the first phase, which will be constructed on church-owned land, the Garden of Eden (a business area) also to be built on state-owned land and Divina Island, a man-made island development to be created off the peninsula.

The artificial ‘luxury lifestyle’ island, will cover 137 hectares, and is to include beachfront villas and a marina with a capacity of 500 boats.

The construction of Eden City has been beset by delays as the government and the consortium have yet to come to an agreement over the annual rent to be paid for the use of state land.

Meanwhile, the list of developers exhibiting an interest in building luxury high-rise accommodation on the southwest coast of the island is growing bigger.

In Paphos, according to a list recently published by the municipality, apart from Aristo Developers who applied for two separate projects consisting of three high-rises, Pafilia Cyprus Property Developers Ltd has also applied for a 12-storey high rise in Kato Paphos.

Korantina Homes known for its investments in the municipality of Peyia is awaiting the green light for an investment which includes two high-rises of 16 and 20-storeys in the city centre. The investment is a co-venture with Russian firm Meridoro Ltd.

CC Pearls Homes Co Ltd also plans to build two 13 and 10-storey buildings, while Prospecta Developers Ltd is also planning a 20-storey high-rise.

In Limassol, already well-established players are leading the high-rise construction sector. Leptos Estates are planning to build two towers of 29 and 35-storeys.

Pafilia Limassol Neo, subsidiary of Pafilia Cyprus Property Developers Ltd, plans to build four towers of 43, 38, 31 and 25-storeys.

Lanitis Group of companies in cooperation with Cybarco are building the Trilogy Limassol Seafront, which will consist of three towers on the city’s coastal road (on 28 October Avenue), with the tallest one being 37-stories high.

Copyright ©2018 Financial Mirror

[youtube=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pc9bOZEPmw8&w=470&rel=0]

Funds eyeing Bank of Cyprus bad loans

Funds eyeing Bank of Cyprus bad loansAPOLLO Global Management, Pacific Investment Management Co. and Lone Star Funds want to buy some of a non-performing loan portfolio, valued at as much as 5 billion euros ($5.9 billion), that Bank of Cyprus Holdings Plc plans to sell, according to people familiar with the matter.

Bank of Cyprus is going to proceed with the so-called Project Helix offering in August, the people said, asking not to be named because the information isn’t public. The lender repeated its position that it would cut its bad loans “through both organic and inorganic activity,” according to an emailed statement from a London-based external spokeswoman for Bank of Cyprus, who declined further comment.

Cypriot and European officials have been urging the nation’s banking sector to reduce the amount of non-performing loans, aiming to avoid a repeat of the island’s 2013 economic crisis. On the buyside, U.S. funds have been circling southern European bank assets, with Lone Star acquiring a multi-billion-euro Spanish property portfolio last month and Pimco eyeing a direct stake in Cyprus’ Hellenic Bank Plc.

A spokesman for Pimco didn’t reply to a request for comment, while spokespeople for Lone Star and Apollo declined to comment.

Despite Cyprus’ vigorous economic upswing, NPLs still weigh on banks’ profitability and have prevented significant improvement in financial health for households and companies, the International Monetary Fund said earlier this month. The European Commission and European Central Bank called on the country’s banks to prioritize reducing NPLs in a joint statement earlier this year.

B2Holding Interest

Other interested parties in the Bank of Cyprus loans include B2Holding ASA, a Norwegian firm specializing in distressed bank loans. It’s interested in co-investing with any buyer of the bad loans, with a view to servicing them, Rakis Christoforou, managing director of the Oslo-based company’s Cypriot arm, B2Kapital, said by phone. In June, B2Kapital completed the purchase of a package of mostly non-retail secured and unsecured exposures from Hellenic Bank valued at about 144 million euros.

Bank of Cyprus reported some progress in its first-quarter earnings report, saying it had reduced bad-loan exposure for a 12th consecutive quarter. As of March 31, bad loan exposure stood at 8.3 billion euros, with a 51 percent coverage ratio, up from 48 percent at the end of 2017, meaning the bank is better able to withstand losses. Non-performing exposures shrank to 45 percent of gross loans from 47 percent at the end of 2017. The bank is targeting a 2-billion-euro “organic” reduction in bad loans this year.

By Paul Tugwell and Georgios Georgiou with assistance by Antonio Vanuzzo

Non-performing loans highest in Europe

Cyprus: Non-performing loans highest in EuropeALMOST a decade after the 2008 real estate bubble bust, Cyprus’ ratio of non-performing loans in the real estate and construction sector remain among the highest in the European Union (EU) and European Economic Area (EEA), the European Banking Authority said.

The non-performing loans ratio of construction companies was 75 per cent in March down from 76 per cent in December which was in both cases the highest in Europe, the EBA said in its quarterly Risk Dashboard report on its website. That of the real estate sector stood at 39 per cent at the end of March, the third highest, down from 43 per cent in December.

The construction and real estate sector in Cyprus, both benefiting from the government’s scheme which allows investors, also in real estate, to obtain a Cypriot passport or a permanent residence permit depending on the size of their investment, saw the size of their respective non-performing loans fall at the end of March to €3.2bn from €3.4bn a quarter before and to €1.4bn from €1.6bn respectively, according to EBA.

The Cypriot government is also supporting both demand and supply in the real estate and construction sector via tax cuts and town planning relaxations. Debt-to-asset swaps, which resulted in banks onboarding more than €2.1bn in real property since 2015, has also helped reduce loan arrears in the island’s construction and real estate sector.

Cyprus’ construction sector output rose last year 25 per cent to €752.9m compared to 2016, which is roughly one third of the all-time high of 2008. Output in the real estate sector rose 2.8 per cent to €1.6bn.

The delinquent loans ratio of the construction sector in Greece was the second highest in Europe at the end of the first quarter with 67 per cent followed by Italy’s 47 per cent and Malta’s 41 per cent, according to the EBA figures. In the real estate sector, the highest ratio was Greece’s 56 per cent followed by Bulgaria’s 40 per cent.

The average non-performing loans ratio in the construction and real estate sectors at the end of March in the EU and EEA was 20 per cent and 5.2 per cent respectively, the EBA said.

The lowest ratios in construction at the end of the first quarter were Norway’s 0.9 per cent, followed by Sweden’s 2.2 per cent and a 3.1 per cent in Denmark, EBA said. In the real estate sector, Sweden boasted a negligible 0.1 per cent, the lowest in Europe, followed by 0.7 per cent in Norway and 0.9 per cent in Denmark.

Total non-performing loans stood in March at €19.9bn or 43 per cent. They are considered a major risk for the Cypriot economy, which expanded last year 3.9 per cent and emerged in 2015 from a prolonged recession which led to a twin fiscal and banking crisis in 2013. On July 8, the parliament passed legislation amending the foreclosure and insolvency framework in an attempt to help banks improve borrower discipline and tackle strategic default.

The banking sector’s exposure to construction was 19 per cent in March, which was three times the average in Europe as well as the highest, the EBA said. Exposure to the real estate sector was 16 per cent, well below the average of 27 per cent.

Further reading

European Banking Authority Risk Dashboard Q1 2018