Arrears and NPLs at unprecedented levels

ARREARS and non-performing loans (NPLs) are rising to unprecedented levels in Cyprus, Central Bank (CBC) Governor Panicos Demetriadies said on Monday.

Speaking at a conference on Arrears Management and Loan Restructurings, organised by the CBC with Irish and EU experts, Demetriades said the IMF December 2013 Cyprus Second Review had provided valuable lessons from Ireland and Iceland as regards NPLs.

“As in the case of Cyprus, these countries entered the crisis with large private sector indebtedness accumulated in the decade preceding the crisis,” said Demetriades.  He said that private sector indebtedness peaked at over 500 per cent of GDP in Iceland, and 300 per cent in Ireland.

“By comparison, private sector indebtedness stands at 300 per cent in Cyprus. One should however place this in context and recognise that while the numbers are high, the problem can be addressed and defused once appropriate and targeted measures are taken, such as a targeted case-by-case approach to debt restructuring, an effective arrears management framework, and the strengthening of the legal framework,” said the Governor.

He said arrears management and loan restructuring was one of the most challenging issues currently facing the banking sector in Cyprus in its path to the restoration of financial soundness.

A reduction in the level of NPLs would result in lower provisioning requirements and this would contribute to the decline in interest rates in the long run, to the benefit of households and businesses.

Banks had started deleveraging and would focus their operations on domestic core banking products, said the Governor.

“Unfortunately, for many years the banking sector in Cyprus, in common with some other countries, adopted poor risk and credit management practices, dominated by asset based lending, and an overexpansion of the real estate market,” Demetriades said.

“The consequences of such practices can be disguised in periods of an expanding booming economy, even appearing as successful while real estate prices are rising, demand remains strong,  and income growth targets supersede the basic principles that should govern any basic business or lending transaction – the ability of borrowers to repay their debts.”

New directives from the CBC, he said, were designed to shift lending from asset based criteria (collateral) to assessing the ability to repay.

“Collateral should be just that, an added layer of security in case things do not evolve as expected, and should not be expected to be the primary source of repayment,” Demetriades said. But he added that a focus on the human factor, especially in cases of home owners, should remain. The emphasis now was on  restructuring loans on the basis of fair pricing in order to achieve a viable repayment schedule which would assist the borrowers’ business and financial condition, contribute to economic recovery and safeguard the interests of banks.

Demetriades said loan restructuring provided an opportunity for banks to strengthen their liquidity and profitability where an improvement in debt servicing performance can be achieved.

Steps taken to address arrears should adhere to the Code of Conduct for borrowers and creditors, with a case by case approach, he said.

“A distinction should be made by banks between those borrowers who are cooperative and willing to meet repayments in line with their financial capacity, and those who are able to repay but are unwilling,” said the Governor.

Decisive recovery measures “should be deployed for able but unwilling clients”, he added.

The CBC boss said that an assessment of the island’s credit institutions internal effectiveness, operational capacity, and arrears management policies, procedures and practices for the different sectors in the market would be conducted in the first half of this year.

The conference, which ends on Tuesday, will cover strategies, treatment of borrowers, and legalities.

Nonperforming loans in Cyprus at unprecedented level

Call for BBC to investigate Cyprus property issues

DURING the past decade thousands of Britons purchased off-plan properties in Cyprus but they were faced with numerous problems including:

a) Sales initiated in this country [UK] do not appear to be regulated by this country [UK];

b) Properties purchased remain in the name of the developer, and could potentially be re-possessed by the Bank that has financed the development; alternatively purchasers have been tied into loans, often in strong currencies that they have little hope of repaying;

c) In all appearances, Cyprus has the same standards as in the UK but what are accepted practices there would be totally unacceptable here and enforcement of serious breaches by Cypriot authorities is seriously lacking.

Due to these problems thousands of Britons have been ruined financially, many, unable to deal with the pressure, are suffering from ill health and a small number have committed suicide.  The British Government has paid lip service to the problem but so far has done little to remedy the situation.

Cyprus had been a British colony since 1878 and despite it gaining independence in 1960 it remains closely associated to Britain due to the British Sovereign Bases and the fact that many thousands of Britons live in Cyprus and visit Cyprus regularly.

Its strategic importance to Anglo-American interests may explain why the British Government has taken a very softly-softly approach with the Cypriot authorities to the detriment of Britons who have been badly caught and should have been protected by Cypriot, British and EU Regulations but there was a combined failure to protect them.

Any investigation will reveal a culture of mis-selling that has been allowed to be operated mostly by British sales agents working on behalf of Cypriot developers and banks, serious failures in the regulatory system in this country and apathy by the British authorities.

Many victims of these deceptions have made formal complaints to the Financial Conduct Authority, the Financial Ombudsman, Action Fraud, the Office of Fair Trading, the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, their local MPs and MEPs, and numerous government ministers.  After many years of campaigning, the closest they have been to any action by politicians is the formation in 2012 of an All Party Parliamentary Group for the Defence of the Interests of British Property Owners in Cyprus which, so far, appears to have little influence on the British and the Cypriot Governments.

In 2010, the BBC exposed some of these issues in the Inside Out and You and Yours programmes. Since then the situation has become much more urgent, problems are in greater need of investigation and publicity and the “what is happening out there” approach taken by these programmes could do with a Panorama investigation highlighting “what can happen to you in home ground” and how you will not be protected by the British Government.

We petition BBC Panorama to undertake a full and balanced investigative report, to expose the failure of the British authorities to protect the victims.

Those wishing to sign the on-line petition calling for a BBC Panorama investigation should visit Investigate the issues facing UK citizens who have purchased off plan properties in the Republic of Cyprus.

Sovereign Base Areas development agreement in full

FULL details of the landmark agreement between Cyprus and the United Kingdom enabling the development of land within the Sovereign Base Areas (SBAs) have been released.

The agreement lifts restrictions on the development of land in the non-military areas in the Sovereign Base Areas that have been in place since Cyprus gained its independence in 1960.

Earlier today President Anastasiades briefed community leaders and party representatives on the agreement, which has been hailed by many as “historic”.

The agreement applies to properties extending to approximately 198 square kilometres, representing 78 per cent of the Sovereign Bases area.

Under the 1960 Treaty of Establishment, properties within the Akrotiri and Dhekelia SBAs could only be used as agricultural land and no building development was permitted.

The agreement will benefit 3 Municipalities and 17 Communities:

  • The Municipalities of Deryneia, Kato Polemidia and Ypsonas.
  • The Communities of Akrotiri, Asomatos, Avdimou, Erimi, Episkopi, Kolossi, Trachoni, Sotira and Paramali in the Limassol district.
  • The Communities of Avgorou, Acheritou, Achna and Frenaros in the Famagusta district.
  • The Communities of Xylotimpou, Xylofagou, Ormidia and Pyla in the Larnaca district.

Most of the communities affected by the agreement have welcomed the new arrangements, but some expressed their doubts as to whether they would be allowed to develop their properties.

Further reading

The arrangement between the government of Cyprus and the government of the United Kingdom relating to the regulation of development in the Sovereign Base Areas.

Building permits slump 39 per cent

THE NUMBER of building permits issued in October stood at 475 compared with the 782 issued in October 2012; a fall of 39%, according to figures released earlier this week by the Cyprus Statistical Service.

Compared with October 2012, the total area of these permits fell 11% to 113,123 square metres from 126,546, while their value fell 34% to €113,257 million from €172,588 million.

During October, building permits were issued for:

  • Residential buildings – 337 permits
  • Non-residential buildings – 70 permits
  • Civil engineering projects – 27 permits
  • Division of plots of land – 32 permits
  • Road construction – 9 permits

During the first ten months of 2013 a total of 4,468 building permits were authorised; a drop of 27% compared with the 6,146 permits issued during the same period last year. Their total value has fallen by 29% and their total area by 28%.

New home construction

The 337 residential building permits approved in October provided for the construction of 354 new homes comprising 135 single houses and 219 multiple housing units (such as apartments, semis, townhouses and other residential complexes).

This is a fall of 24% compared with October 2012 when building permits were issued for the construction of 469 new homes.

During the first nine months of 2013, the number of new homes for which permits were authorised has fallen by 29% compared with the same period last year.

building permits October 2013

According to the Cyprus Statistical Service, building permits constitute a leading indicator of future activity in the construction sector.

House prices down by 1.3 per cent

HOUSE prices, as measured by the House Price Index (HPI), fell by 1.3% in the euro area and by 0.5% in the EU in the third quarter of 2013 compared with the same quarter of the previous year, according to data published by Eurostat, the statistical office of the European Union.

Compared with the second quarter of 2013, house prices rose by 0.6% in the euro area and by 0.7% in the EU in the third quarter of 2013.

House prices in EU Member States

Among the EU Member States for which data are available, the highest annual increases in house prices in the third quarter of 2013 were recorded in:

  • Estonia (+11.1%)
  • Luxembourg (+6.5%, flats only)
  • Latvia (+6.2%)

and the largest falls were recorded in:

  • Croatia (-16.9%)
  • Cyprus (-8.0%)
  • Spain (-6.4%)

The highest quarterly increases in the third quarter of 2013 were recorded in Estonia (+5.3%), Ireland (+4.1%), and the United Kingdom (+2.5%), and the largest falls in Slovenia (-4.0%), Denmark (-3.3%) and Romania (-2.4%).

Further reading

Eurostat News Release 9/2014 – 21 January 2014

Property tax review gets underway

ACCORDING to reports in the local media, the Cyprus government has appointed PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) as an advisor on the formation of a single framework for the taxation of real estate.

Headquartered in London, PwC is a multinational professional services firm headquartered in London. It is the world’s second largest professional services firm, measured by 2013 revenues, and is one of the Big Four auditors along with Deloitte, Ernst & Young (EY) and KPMG.

Work should be completed in 3 months.

Meanwhile, the Cyprus Land and Building Developers Association has presented its recommendations for property tax reforms to the government. These include:

  • Individual properties should be taxed separately, based on their estimated value. (Currently, Immovable Property Tax is calculated on the total 1980 values of all the properties registered in the name of the taxpayer).
  • The amount of tax should be increased to include the payment of all the other taxes, duties and fees associated with owning a property that are levied by the Inland Revenue, municipalities, and communities together with sewerage charges, which are also based on a property’s value.
  • Those who have bought property and lodged their contracts of sale at the Land Registry for Specific Performance should also pay property tax. I.e. those who have yet to receive the deeds to a property they purchased will be liable, rather than the property’s registered owner (the developer).

The Association believes that its proposals will reduce the administrative costs of calculating and collecting taxes, which will benefit both the authorities and taxpayers.

The Association has also proposed a 10% discount on the tax payable, providing it is paid by the deadline, plus a further 5% discount if it is paid electronically.

It has also suggested that interest charged by the Inland Revenue for late payment should be reduced to 4.75% from its present level of 9% to bring it into line with other interest charges imposed by the state for late payment and hopes that the Inland Revenue will introduce payment by instalments.