Discussion on old mortgages bill postponed

Discussion on old mortgages bill postponedTHE HOUSE finance committee on Monday said it would for the time being sit on a bill proposing that mortgages granted prior to passage of the foreclosures law on September 9, 2014 be exempted from foreclosure proceedings.

The legislative proposal was tabled by independent MP Anna Theologou. It is co-sponsored by Edek’s Marinos Sizopoulos and the Greens’ Giorgos Perdikis.

Committee chair Averof Neophytou (Disy) said the majority of MPs on the committee decided to wait for a package of government bills related to the issue of non-performing loans (NPLs).

Last month the government said it was in the process of preparing proposals on how to improve the insolvency and foreclosure laws in a bid to tackle NPLs, especially those held by the state-owned co-op bank.

Current legislation, passed in 2015, makes it difficult for banks to recover their money, something repeatedly pointed out by the EU and the IMF.

The co-op bank has the biggest exposure to loans with primary residences as collateral. In 2017, co-ops extended the collateral recovery period to seven years, a move that cost €150m in provisions.

Neophytou said that Theologou’s proposal, as well as any others submitted by other MPs, would be discussed together once the government bills are tabled.

“We shall wait for all the proposals so the matter can be discussed and decided in its totality,” he said.

Earlier, officials from the government and the central bank had warned that Theologou’s proposal would wreak havoc on banks’ balance sheets, as it would strip them of the power to exert pressure on debtors not keeping up with their mortgage payments.

Officials said European institutions would have to conclude that the foreclosures and repossessions system in Cyprus is ineffectual, and as a result request that Cypriot banks raise their capital provisions.

Akel deputy Stefanos Stefanou accused the government of dragging its feet on the issue:

“It convened meetings at the presidential palace, it committed to bringing proposals. None of that has happened yet,” he noted.

Also on Monday MPs gave the go-ahead to the government’s appointment of two non-executive members to the board of the Cyprus Cooperative Bank.

The appointments are also subject to the approval of the Central Bank of Cyprus and of the European Central Bank (ECB).

As a systemic lender, the Cyprus Cooperative Bank is under the supervision of the ECB.

Limit on citizenship scheme announced

THE COUNCIL of ministers decided on Monday to limit the number of naturalisations of investors granted under the citizenship by investment scheme to 700 a year, starting this year.

The citizenship-by-investment scheme will also be renamed the “Cypriot Investment Scheme”, the Press and Information Office (PIO) said in an announcement after the cabinet meeting.

Every application will also be subjected to an enhanced due diligence, the PIO said, after the cabinet meeting.

Applicants, who will foot the bill for the enhanced due diligence process, will have to wait up to six months for their applications to be examined.

“A code of conduct has been adopted with clear provisions to avoid exaggerations and abusive practices,” it said. While investors have to remain owners of their investment for a minimum three-year period, in the case of buyers of real estate, the period now begins with the issue of a town planning permit.

The government’s golden visa scheme introduced in the current form in 2014 and amended on a number of occasions thereafter, allows investors to receive Cypriot citizenship for an investment of as little as €2m.

In 2017, the government issued 503 passports to an equal number of investors and 510 additional passports to members of their respective families, compared to 443 and 461 in 2016, 337 and 342 in 2015, and 214 and 186 in 2014.

In March, the European Commission said that it would investigate golden visa schemes of member states and prepare a report amid complaints that such schemes were vulnerable to abuse, undermined the fight against corruption and increased the risk of money laundering.

Sewerage blocks Title Deeds

WHILE banks are preventing some of those who bought property in Cyprus from obtaining their Title Deeds through court rulings that judged the ‘trapped buyers’ law unconstitutional, other buyers are blocked from obtaining deeds due to developers flagrantly breaching their planning conditions.

I receive numerous emails from purchasers who cannot get their deeds because developers have encroached on someone else’s land or they haven’t built, roads, pavements, green areas, etc. or they’ve built boundary walls too high, while others have issues with their properties as they fail to meet fire and swimming pool regulations.

For some reason the Cypriot authorities that issue planning and building permits are either unwilling or unable to pursue developers who break the rules and so it is left to the purchasers to pay for the work necessary to obtain ‘clean’ Title Deeds.

One of the key problems is that there is no independent inspection of properties as they are being built as there are in many other countries. The ‘supervising engineer’ who is employed by the developer is responsible for monitoring construction work. Even if the engineer spots something wrong there is nothing they can do about it apart from bringing the issue to the attention of the developer and refusing to sign a ‘Certificate of Completion’.

Independent inspections of properties as they are being built could identify issues as they occur and the authorities could take appropriate action to ensure developers correct them (assuming the inspectors had the necessary powers to intervene and stop further building work until the issues have been rectified.)

Currently in Cyprus independent property inspections only occur after construction work has been completed, which could be several years after the properties have been sold and occupied by their purchasers. Clearly this is far too late to identify and correct planning infringements.

A disgruntled buyer contacted me recently to report on the progress he’d made towards getting the Title Deed for the property he purchased more than a decade ago.

When he purchased the property, he had high hopes of obtaining the Title Deeds fairly quickly. He had good reason to be confident – the contract of sale, which was duly lodged at the Land Registry, included a clause that the developer would do his best not delay the issue of Title Deeds. However, more than a decade later there is no sign of a Title Deed. He considers that rather than doing his best not to delay the issue of Title Deeds, his developer has done his utmost to prevent them being issued.

When the news broke about the Title Deed mess he contacted his ‘independent’ lawyer for help. But he soon discovered that his so-called ‘independent’ lawyer batted for the other team.

Eventually he took matters into his own hands and made enquiries to uncover any issues that would prevent Title Deeds being issued.  As a result of enquiries at his local Land Registry office and Municipality he discovered a number of things the developer had failed to do. However, with the assistance of the Municipality he was able to resolve most of the issues himself save for one – his development’s waste water system.

Rather than the more usual waste water system employing septic tanks and absorption pits, one of the conditions on the planning application was that the developer should construct and install a biological waste water system to comply with the Water Pollution Control Law. Biological waste water systems are significantly more expensive than septic tank and absorption pit systems and the developer probably broke his planning conditions to save money.

This issue lay undetected for nearly a decade and only came to light through enquiries at the Municipality, by which time it was far too late to help the hapless buyers who found themselves in the mess.

Those who bought property on this development consider there have been many people to blame along the way but it is they, the unsuspecting buyers, that suffer and who are left to pick up the pieces.

The developer flatly refuses to cooperate or pay to correct his failure which may cost upwards of €30,000. Theirs is a small development and raising this sort of money is out of their reach.  Through no fault of their own they find themselves in a position where their properties will be immensely difficult to sell and are practically worthless.

I wonder how many other nefarious property developers have breached the conditions of their planning consent to save money that their purchasers are forced to pay to get their Title Deeds?

This is a scandalous situation and blatantly unfair!

Online rented property regulation

Property for rent in CyprusPROPOSALS to regulate the licencing of property whose owner rents them online through organisations such as AirBnB have been put before the House by MPs Averoff Neophytou (DISY)and Elias Myrianthous (EDEK).

Their proposals would amend the current law on hotels and tourist accommodation by adding provisions that would include the registration and licencing of “self-handled” accommodation (furnished villas and other dwellings). They will also set a licencing framework, technical and functional specifications and other terms and conditions relating to ‘self-catering’ property offered for rent.

The proposals are part of an overall drive to upgrade the quality of the tourist product of Cyprus.

The proposed register of self-catering accommodation will be created and managed by the Cyprus Tourism Organisation (CTO) and based on regulations adopted by the Council of Ministers These will include the criteria and specifications that self-catering accommodation should meet. (Note that the CTO is to be transformed into a State Department of Tourism).

Owners of self-catering accommodation will be required to register with the Tax Department.

Cyprus property: biggest in Europe

Cyprus property: biggest in EuropeTHE AVERAGE size of a Cyprus property (dwelling) is 141.4 square metres and it’s the largest in Europe according to the league table published by Eurostat.

Commenting on the figures, Cystat said “If a person lives in a house with an area of more than 141,4m2, he/she lives in a residence that is above the average size of dwellings in Cyprus, which has the biggest average size in the EU.”

The country with the lowest average size of dwelling is Romania at 43.9 square metres compared to the EU average of 95.9 square metres.

Coming in silver medal position in the ‘mine is bigger than yours’ chart is Luxembourg with an average dwelling size of 131.1 square metres, while Iceland takes bronze with 130.4 square metres.

Although the average size of a Cyprus property takes the gold medal, it’s probably at the bottom of the world league table for the time it takes to issue Title Deeds for its properties.

Here’s the full list of the ‘mine is bigger than yours’ league table published by Eurostat.

Country Average Dwelling
size (sqm)
Cyprus 141.4
Luxembourg 131.1
Iceland 130.4
Belgium 124.3
Norway 122.7
Denmark 118.1
Switzerland 117.2
Netherlands 106.7
Portugal 106.4
Austria 99.7
Sweden 99.7
Spain 99.1
Germany 94.3
France 93.7
Italy 93.6
Greece 88.6
Finland 88.6
Slovakia 87.4
Croatia 81.6
Ireland 80.8
Slovenia 80.3
Czech Republic 78.0
Hungary 75.6
Poland 75.2
Bulgaria 73.0
Estonia 66.7
Lithuania 63.2
Latvia 62.5
Romania 43.9
Malta (u)
United Kingdom (u)

Unfortunately, the figures Malta and the United Kingdom were unavailable. As the UK is still using yards, feet and inches and is focussing its attentions on BREXIT negotiations, the unavailability of figures is quite understandable.

Anyone for a pint?

Reduce non-performing loans by 40% in 2018

huge non-performing loansTHE CYPRUS Finance Ministry outlined a three-pillar strategy aiming to swiftly reduce the level of non-performing loans by 40% in 2018 or €8.2 billion, compared with 2017.

According to the Stability Programme for 2018-2021 issued yesterday, the plan provides for a series of reforms in legal framework governing NPL management, the sale of the Cyprus Cooperative Bank and the implementation of a scheme called “ESTIA” to use public money to help households repay mortgage loans secured by primary residences.

By end 2017, total NPLs in the Cypriot banking sector amounted to 20.6 billion or 44% of total loans, the second highest percentage in the EU following Greece.

“The Government has set as a priority to effectively and swiftly tackle the most challenging issue facing the financial sector and the broader economy,” the Finance Ministry notes, adding “to this end a comprehensive strategy has been designed in order to successfully resolve, during the course of 2018, the final hurdle to full normalization of the economy that of non-performing facilities (NPFs) burdening the banking sector.”

The first pillar involves a series of reforms in the legal framework governing the NPL management, including the introduction of electronic auctions of foreclosed property, the improvement of the foreclosure framework “to act as a credible thread especially to strategic defaulters,” and the completion of a secondary NPL market.

According to the document, published by the Finance Ministry, the second pillar of the Government’s strategy addresses the most challenging segment among NPFs in the entire system, that of mortgage non-performing loans and non-performing loans collateralized with the primary residence of the borrower.

According to the FinMin, “it is envisaged that for the participation in the scheme, eligible portfolio will be NPFs that have been classified as such in 2017 while borrowers should meet specific pre-defined income and asset criteria in order to exclude free riders or strategic defaulters exploiting the government’s support, thus ensuring fairness and limiting moral hazard.”

The third pillar, concerns the privatisation process of the state-owned Cyprus Cooperative Bank launched in March this year. The CCB faces mounting NPLs amounting close to 60% and a provisioning gap due to capital requirements by the ECB.

“In order to meet supervising requirements, a process has been initiated which includes selling the whole or part of assets and liabilities of the CCB,” the Finance Ministry said.

Sources say that the most likely scenario favoured by the ECB is the sale of the performing part of the bank along with part of its branch network. In case this scenario is materialised, the CCB’s NPLs totalling €6.2 billion in end-2017 will be transferred to a state-owned Asset Management Company leading to the reduction of the total NPLs in the system by 30%.

“The above strategy aims at successfully and swiftly addressing the last remaining challenge of the banking sector in the course of 2018 with the objective of reducing the NPLs of the sector significantly, as much as 40%”, the Finance Ministry said.

It added that the strategy’s annual impact is estimated at 0.3 to 0.4% of GDP.