Tenancy Disputes in Cyprus

Landlord and tenant dispute in CyprusDISPUTES between Landlord and Tenant are not uncommon and are most often exacerbated by the differing expectations of the parties. On the one hand, the Landlord is allowing another person to live in his property (the value of which he knows only too well) and on the other hand the Tenant is paying to live there and expects to be able to fully enjoy the premises without interruption.

It is pretty much universally agreed that, if a dispute should occur, it is preferable for the matter to be dealt with between the parties rather than resorting to time-consuming and costly court proceedings. But what are the most common kinds of tenancy dispute and how can they be avoided?

Property Damage

One of the biggest causes of dispute between Landlord and Tenant concerns damage to the property. The Tenant has the duty to return the property in the same condition as it was delivered to him, fair wear and tear excepted.

This means that any damage which is caused by the reasonable use of the premises by the Tenant or the passage of time will not be damage for which the Tenant is responsible. A common sense approach to what is “fair wear and tear” should be adopted considering the individual circumstances of the tenancy, for example one can expect greater damage to a property which is let to young families or smokers.

Return of the Deposit

Closely linked to the issue of wear and tear is the return of the deposit. The Landlord will usually take the equivalent of between one and two month’s rent as a deposit, as security against damage to the property. At the end of the tenancy he will assess the cost of any damage and will deduct this cost from the amount returned to the Tenant. As mentioned above, he may make deductions for any damage which is beyond “fair wear and tear” but the law does not impose an obligation on the Tenant to improve the property or leave it in a better state than that in which he took it.

Repairs

Another bone of contention can be repairs. Responsibility for routine repairs to the property ought to be made clear in the Tenancy Agreement. Most often, the Landlord will be responsible for the bulk of the general maintenance in relation to the property. As a general rule he should keep the property in the condition it was rented in, for example if it is rented with air conditioning he will be responsible for ensuring that the air conditioning remains operational.

Rent Review

The increase of rent may also cause friction. It is clearly in the Tenant’s interests to keep the rent as low as possible but as time goes by and the costs of living and repairs increase and individual property values go up, Landlords will wish to increase the level of rent to reflect this. The law in Cyprus places certain restrictions on rental increase which mean that the rent may not be increased by any more than 14% in any two year period.

Non-Payment of Rent

Punctual payment of rent is of course one of the Landlord’s greatest concerns. Where payment is not promptly made, the Landlord should issue written warnings to the Tenant. Where these are not successful then the Landlord may issue a Termination Notice to evict the Tenant and may seek to recover the outstanding rent in the Court, together with interest.

Avoiding Problems

As a Landlord, many of the issues associated with tenants can be avoided by:

Careful Tenant Selection – This means checking references as to stability in employment and previous tenancies as well checking the financial standing of the Tenant.

Preparation of an Inventory – An inventory detailing the condition of the fixtures and fittings and any furniture in the property (preferably with photos) will help to ensure that there is no dispute regarding the level of wear and tear.

Agreement in Writing – An essential tool to protect both parties is a detailed tenancy agreement drawn up by a lawyer specialising in such matters which outlines the full expectations and responsibilities of the parties. To be effective, a rental agreement in Cyprus must be signed by both parties and witnessed by two witnesses.

Final Inspection – At the end of the tenancy a joint final inspection will help the parties to agree any damage and necessary deductions from the deposit to cover such damages.

Conclusion

The relationship between Landlord and Tenant can be a fragile one. Those which tend to deteriorate are usually the relationships where the expectations of the parties differ and this will be most likely to occur when the parties have not embodied their prior expectations in writing.

A thorough rental agreement prepared by a legal professional will not only outline the exact responsibilities of the parties but may also allow for certain recourse when problems do occur (for example deductions from the deposit) which will substantially reduce the chances of having to resort to litigation in order to resolve the dispute.

About the author

Louise Zambartas is the Head of Private Client Department of L.G. Zambartas LLC, Law Offices; one of only eight law firms on the list of lawyers published by the British High Commission in Nicosia.

Cyprus Bar to advise lawyers after landmark ruling

THE CYPRUS BAR Association has decided to advise its members on the broader range of duties placed on legal practitioners following last month’s landmark Supreme Court ruling on legal negligence.

The Supreme Court awarded a British couple around €120,000 in compensation as a result of their Paphos lawyer’s negligence in a property case, marking a first in Cyprus.

Head of the Bar Association, Doros Ioannides, told the Sunday Mail yesterday that the landmark case was discussed during last Thursday’s monthly board meeting.

We discussed what are the liabilities and extra duties of lawyers arising from the judgement from a legal point of view and also how to advise lawyers,” said Ioannides.

We agreed to explain to lawyers the decision and what obligations, undertakings, liabilities arise as a result regarding out of court activities,” he said, noting that this involved all practices, not just property transactions.

Ioannides acknowledged that the Supreme Court decision widened the responsibilities and liabilities of lawyers.

It’s a decision which puts some guidelines down so a lawyer has to be careful towards his client. What we will give is not binding, just advice.

Ioannides noted that as of January 1, 2010, all lawyers are obliged to take professional indemnity or else they can not renew their practising lawyer’s licence.

If a client wants to get compensation they can either go to court or sort it out with the insurance company in an out-of-court settlement.

Asked whether he agreed with the court decision, he replied: “I don’t disagree with the decision as a whole. There is professional negligence in every profession, whether you are a doctor, lawyer or driver.

The decision is likely to have sent alarm bells ringing among those lawyers who may have been following unsafe practices, particularly on property issues.

The British couple involved in the landmark case sued their Paphos lawyer Nicos Papacleovoulou for negligently handling a property contract in 1999, which led to them losing a significant amount of money while never receiving the property.

The lawyer had failed to inform the couple that the property had been twice mortgaged and had a charge registered against it. The developer who signed the contract subsequently went bankrupt and never finished the house.

Following an 11-year pursuit of justice, which cost them their relationship and the man’s health, the British couple finally had their day in court last month when the top judges ordered the lawyer to pay full compensation to the couple for money lost as a result of his negligence.

The couple’s Nicosia-based lawyer, Nicholas Georghiades, the first lawyer in Cyprus to take on a colleague in a negligence case, described the ruling as “outstanding” and “the best case scenario” since “it set a very good precedent, fully explaining a lawyer’s duties”.

It was the first case of a lawyer’s negligence in Cyprus and the first time that the top court chose to lay out the duties and obligations of a lawyer vis-a-vis their clients, providing the basis for any future case against negligent lawyers, particularly on title deeds.

Speaking after the ruling, Georghiades explained there was no previous case law in Cyprus, meaning he had to rely on English authorities that might not necessarily be adopted. “In England, the law society has special rules on conveyancing practice. There’s no such thing in Cyprus,” he said.

New title search procedures in Cyprus

Cyprus: Land Registry SearchPROSPECTIVE buyers trying to obtain information about mortgages and other claims against a property they are thinking of buying often run into ‘difficulties’ as the Cyprus Land Registries are reluctant to divulge this information to the public.

In Cyprus, the Land Registries will only disclose information on the status of Title Deeds, mortgages, etc. to ‘interested parties’, due to the fact that the laws of Cyprus are very different to those of England and Wales:

In England and Wales

The Land Registry operates an open register which means that copies of all documents referred to on the registered title can be obtained by anyone, subject to payment of the necessary fee.

In Cyprus

Information or documents in the public register of Titles connected with the ownership of immovable properties and charges or encumbrances lodged against them are treated as confidential and unavailable for public inspection.

(This effectively prevents a potential property buyer finding out whether the property he/she is thinking of buying is mortgaged until after they have signed a contract of sale to purchase it; by which time of course, it is too late!)

New procedures to overcome the problem

TO OVERCOME this problem Andreas Symeou, a senior official at the Department of Lands and Surveys, recently sent a circular to all the District Lands Offices in Cyprus with instructions to provide prospective purchasers with all relevant information regarding the property they are considering purchasing.

These should make it much easier for those who are thinking of buying a property in Cyprus to discover whether or not it has been mortgaged by the developer.

The District Lands Offices will now supply information on the status of a property’s Title Deeds to potential property buyers providing that he/she he produces:

  • Confirmation by the Owner/prospective vendor that he is a prospective purchaser or
  • Contract of sale signed by the vendor (but not necessarily by the prospective purchaser) or
  • Any other similar document.

Guide to obtaining a Title search

It will take staff a few days to carry out the search and provide you with a comprehensive report on the status of the property’s Title. The cost is just a few Euros and is money well spent. Proceed as follows:

  • Take the completed forms with you to the District Lands Office in which the property is situated – Nicosia, Limassol, Larnaca, Paphos, Famagusta or Paralimni along with your passport.

Obviously, if a vendor refuses to complete an Authorisation or a Confirmation Form or refuses to provide a Contract of Sale signed by just himself, it is reasonable to assume that there are problems with the property’s Title Deed. In these situations you are strongly advised to look elsewhere for a less risky purchase.

(Click here to download the circular and forms issued to the Land Registries by Andreas Symiou in Greek – plus an English translation of the circular and forms – plus the N.50 search form in Greek & English)

AIPP gets tough on North Cyprus agents

AIPP members could face expulsion from the trade body if they refuse to stop selling homes in Northern Cyprus.

The UK-based organisation already prevents entry to companies who market homes in the Turkish-controlled part of Cyprus.

But at its annual general meeting last week, the AIPP decided to extend the ban to its existing membership.

CEO Mark Sharp stressed that the decision would make the group’s policy consistent and was not designed as a political statement.

We could count the number of members this affects on the fingers of one hand,” he told OPP.

Legal change

Members that sell property in Northern Cyprus will be given a timeframe in which to stop and will be subject to disciplinary sanctions – including possible expulsion – if they don’t.

The North’s property industry has been under scrutiny since British couple David and Linda Orams were sued by the original Greek Cypriot owner of the land their holiday home was built on.

The case came to a head earlier this year when a European Court ruling forced the couple to abandon the property and schedule a demolition. Thousands more foreign owners are thought to be at similar risk.

Sharp refused to comment on the fact that some agents claim to be able to source property with pre-1974 title deeds.

We were waiting for legal clarification in the form of the Orams case and now we have to make a stand,” he said.

What we have said is that if the situation does change we would look at it again.

New board

The AIPP also welcomed six new board members at the meeting: Stuart Law of Assetz, Nick Turner of The Registry Collection, Ray Withers of Property Frontiers, Ayse Ozcan of Acacia International, Andrea Marston of Montenegro Prospects, and Dave Burgess of The Hotel Investment Company.

Lindsay Hopkins and Sue Ash were reappointed to the Board having retired by rotation, with Hopkins to serve a second year as the AIPP’s Chair.

Overseas Property Professional

Property rights campaigner to appear in court

Paphos District Court
Paphos District Court

DENIS O’HARE has been summonsed to appear in the Paphos District Court at 9:30 on Thursday 20th May following a writ moved against him by Armonia Estates Ltd and Pantelis Leptos, according to a source within the Cyprus Property Action Group (CPAG).

Armonia Estates Limited is part of the Leptos Group and operates under the brand name Leptos Estates; Pantelis Leptos is Vice-chairman of Leptos Group and Marketing Director of Leptos Estates.

The plaintiffs are claiming hundreds of thousands of Euros from Mr O’Hare who has vowed to defend any libel claims vigorously.

Speaking to the Overseas Property Professional magazine last week, Mr O’Hare said “I am absolutely shocked and dismayed at this action.

All I’ve tried to do is lobby the government, help buyers and fix the property problems in Cyprus for everyone’s benefit. This is a sad day for the Cyprus property industry.

A leading Cypriot lawyer commented that this appalling turn of events would create a nightmare situation for Cyprus developers and the government and that the good developers will suffer along with the bad.

In light of actions taken against Mr O’Hare, some believe that CPAG will be resurrected as a an entirely different organisation, with substantial funding and backing, a far more ‘strident’ strategy and a global reach in terms of communication and influence.

A statement issued by Leptos Estates in response to an earlier article on the ‘gagging order’ against Mr O’Hare said “…it is our duty to take all appropriate actions in order to safeguard our company’s reputation.”

Mr O’Hare was unavailable for comment on this latest turn of events.

We have not learnt our lesson

UNFORTUNATELY, despite the fact that we have had many bad experiences when selling property to foreigners, we haven’t learnt our lesson.

We treat the subject very lightly and then when something goes wrong, we rush to deal with it, by which time it is too late.

A prime example was the event that took place at the exhibition “A Place in the Sun” in London, when Conor O’Dwyer protested outside the exhibition together with his family. O’Dwyer maintained that he bought property in the free area of Famagusta, which was sold for a second time by the developer without his knowledge and he lost money.

We are sure that before O’Dwyer resorted to the protest outside the property exhibition, he must have tried other forms of protest to be heard but had been unsuccessful.

And it is here that the relevant government authorities have a responsibility. If they were as methodical as the private sector and reacted openly and immediately, then we are sure that the problem would have been solved right from the beginning and there would have been no need for the protest in London.

This particular type of incident is not unique. We have seen reports of similar incidents in the past. And it is such incidents that discredit Cyprus internationally, wiping out any gains that have resulted from promotions and advertising that unfortunately only the private sector pays for.

Since we want to promote Cyprus as a destination to buy and invest in property, we should sort out these problems at their root and not let the situation get out of hand in the way that happened recently in London.

The state should intervene dynamically and the Interior Ministry which is responsible for this sector should place this specific problem under its scrutiny. Furthermore, it should take the necessary steps to ensure that such unacceptable incidents never happen again.

We will go one step further and propose that a relevant service be set up that will function correctly and pre-emptively in such instances.

At the same time, the necessary funds should be made available so that we can promote Cyprus in the property sector abroad. And why not, we should combine this with promoting Cyprus as a tourist destination and in this way also promote holiday homes. This should be a joint effort with developers who are also promoting Cyprus extensively.

Finally, it is sad that on the one hand millions are spent on publicity to promote Cyprus and great efforts are being made to deal with the problems of Title Deeds, while on the other hand it is all blown away by a single incident such as the one experienced in London and for which Cyprus earned the name “a shame in the sun”.

George Mouskides is Chairman of the Association for the Promotion of Property Development and Manager of Fox Smart Estate Agency.